A weary detective and a plucky nun team up to solve a string of gruesome ritual murders in a new drama also created by Jon Robin Baitz and Joe Baken.

Ryan Murphy’s new horror story — but not that horror story — got underway Wednesday night. But did the fear auteur’s latest series put a shiver in your quiver like the trailer promised? Read on for the highlights of the series premiere.

Betts as Detective Lois Tryon and Michaela Diamond as her nun-journalist sidekick Sister Megan as the two attempt to solve the heinous crimes that have been plaguing the town. Lois feels taunted by the crimes as they have hit a little close to home.